About these numbers
Sixteen series from NYC Open Data, loaded with their provenance intact. Every chart links back to the dataset it came from.
They are not interchangeable with national figures.
This instance exists to test where a city's data can and cannot be set against the UN SDG framework — and most pairs fail. Each variable carries a comparability grade and the reason for it; open any variable in the Knowledge Graph browser to read it.
Four that catch people:
- Infant deaths counts deaths under 1. The UN's child mortality indicator counts under 5. Both are raw counts, so the units agree and a chart of the two would look perfectly correct.
- Pregnancy-associated deaths counts any death within a year of pregnancy — deliberately broader than the UN's maternal mortality.
- Municipal waste covers DSNY residential and institutional collection only. Commercial waste is excluded, so NYC's figure is an undercount and its true standing is worse, not better.
- 2020 is absent from every per-100,000 series. There is no ACS 1-year release for 2020, and an interpolated denominator yields a rate indistinguishable from a measured one.
Method, the graded crosswalk and what failed: sarapis.github.io/undatacommons-nyc. Figures are NYC's own measurements, not UN estimates.
One number, two publishers
Homicide is the only concept where this instance holds both a New York series we loaded and an independent series from the base Data Commons graph, for the same city. They do not agree.
Our series comes from NYPD complaint records via NYC Open Data. The base-graph series comes from the FBI's Uniform Crime Reporting. Compared as raw counts across 16 overlapping years, the mean difference is +0.4% and 12 of 16 years agree within 5% — good evidence our query is right.
Then it stops. Through 2022 the FBI runs about 2% above NYPD. From 2023 the sign flips and the gap triples: 385 against 345 in 2023, 363 against 325 in 2024, about 10% below. The FBI series is missing 2021 entirely, which points at its move to NIBRS-only reporting and figures not yet revised — a reading of the shape of the data, not something confirmed against FBI documentation.
Same concept, same city, same year, two official publishers, ten per cent apart, and nothing on a chart tells you which one you are looking at. Our series is a rate per 100,000 and the FBI's is a count, so the two must not share an axis here.
The NYC data in this instance
Every series is citywide
(geoId/3651000). The New York place page shows federal
statistics from the base graph, not these — use the links below.
Environment and waste
- Fine particulate matter (PM2.5), annual mean
Citywide annual mean from NYCCAS ground monitors. why it may not compare - Municipal waste collected, short tons (monthly)
260 monthly points. The clearest thing here that a national graph cannot do. why it may not compare - Municipal waste collected, short tons (annual)
The same rows summed to years. why it may not compare - Municipal waste collected, kg per person
Per person. 2020 is absent — no ACS 1-year release. why it may not compare - Share of DSNY-collected waste recycled
Derived diversion rate. Residential collection only. why it may not compare - Waste delivered to DSNY disposal facilities
Summed across the disposal facilities DSNY used. ~3.2M tons a year. why it may not compare - “Other organics” collected (fiscal year)
DSNY's narrow residual stream, NOT the city's organics programme. Fiscal years. why it may not compare
Health
- Infant deaths (under 1 year)
Under 1, not under 5. The UN indicator counts under 5. why it may not compare - Pregnancy-associated deaths
Any death within a year of pregnancy — broader than maternal mortality. why it may not compare - Deaths attributable to PM2.5, age 30+, per 100,000
Age-adjusted, 30+, PM2.5 specifically. why it may not compare
Safety
- Intentional homicide, per 100,000 people
NYPD murder and non-negligent manslaughter, per 100k. why it may not compare - Intentional homicide, count (NYPD)
The same NYPD count before the denominator — comparable with the FBI's series. why it may not compare - Road traffic deaths, per 100,000 people
Vision Zero collision records, per 100k. why it may not compare
Water (DEP)
- Water consumption, million gallons per day
1960 onward — the longest series here. Peaks at 1,512 MGD in 1979, 1,002 in 2024. why it may not compare - Water consumption, gallons per person per day
177 gallons per person per day in 1970, 118 in 2024. DEP's own denominator. why it may not compare
Housing
- Class C housing maintenance violations
Immediately hazardous violations — an enforcement output, not a housing census. why it may not compare
By community district
- Map: municipal waste collected, all 59 community districts
Tons by default. Tick “Per capita” for tons per resident: the population is the Census 5-year estimate for 2020–2024, summed over the census tracts that approximate each district. For any other year the platform divides by the nearest of those five, so read per-person figures before 2020 as approximate. Bronx Community District 2 reads 4.5x the median district per resident in 2024. That is DSNY’s tonnage for the district divided by the people who live there; this page does not know what else DSNY collects there, so do not read it as what residents throw away. The 59 districts sum to the citywide series above, month by month. - Timeline: the two largest and two smallest districts in 2025
Queens Community District 7 moves +36% from 2017 to 2018, with no matching change in any other district. The step is in DSNY’s own data; this page does not know why.